the Great Satan.
MONSANTO our new
"safe" food supplier
'Last ghost' of the Vietnam
than three decades after the fall of Saigon, the spectre of Agent Orange still
haunts the estimated three million children and grandchildren of its initial
victims. As Vietnam presses a reluctant U.S. government to help mop up the
damage, the taint of the chemical concoction still lingers in a sleepy Ontario
farming town that brewed millions of litres of the stuff for the American war
GEOFFREY YORK AND HAYLEY MICK
From Saturday's Globe
July 12, 2008 at 12:05 AM EDT
Hanoi and Elmira, Ont. —
When the white powder started falling from the sky, the soldiers were puzzled.
Usually the American planes dropped bombs. Now, they were unleashing clouds of
something that looked like fog, smelled like garlic and burned their
"The whole earth was covered with it," remembers Tong Van Vinh, who
was a 26-year-old truck driver in the North Vietnamese military at the time. "We
thought they were dropping smoke bombs on us. We didn't know it was a
A few weeks later, Mr. Vinh began to understand the terrible
power of the strange clouds. "The trees died. Even the grass died. When we went
to collect branches and leaves to disguise our trucks, there were none
This was Agent Orange doing its job. Keen to destroy the enemy's
crops as well as the forest concealing its troop movements and supply lines,
U.S. forces had resorted to the most powerful defoliants they could find,
dropping about 80 million litres in all. But the chemical concoction killed more
than plants; laced with dioxin, it was one of the more toxic substances known to
humanity – so toxic, in fact, that the man who invented Agent Orange spent much
of his life trying to keep it from being used.
Nguyen Thi Kieu Nhung sits inside her family home next to the
Danang airbase in Danang, Vietnam on Thursday, May 21, 2007. The girl was born
with physical deformities, including twisted limbs, a misshapen head, and
protruding eyes suspected by local health officials to have been caused by
dioxin in the chemical defoliant Agent Orange. (David Guttenfelder/Associated Press)
"Nothing that you do in
science is guaranteed to result in benefits for mankind," said U.S. biologist
Arthur Galston, who died last month at the age of 88. "Any discovery ... can be
turned either to constructive ends or destructive ends."
As the North
Vietnamese soldiers were to discover, the "destructive ends" for Agent Orange
were anything but fleeting; in fact, they have yet to subside. More than three
decades after the fall of Saigon, the scourge known as the "last ghost" of the
Vietnam War still haunts the children, and now the grandchildren, of its initial
victims – an estimated three million people.
First sprayed in 1968, Mr.
Vinh was plagued by muscular and skeletal disorders. But after the war ended in
1975, his health deteriorated rapidly. By 1994, he was paralyzed and spent six
months in hospital, being fed liquids through his nose. He recovered, but not
enough to work on his rice farm. Today, his voice is hoarse, he can't swallow
solid food, his spine is numb and often he is too weak to walk or even to turn
over in bed.
Dioxin interferes with reproduction, so Mr. Vinh's nightmare
swept up his children and grandchildren as well. One son is blind and mentally
handicapped. Another is deaf. A third has spinal problems. One daughter is
partly paralyzed, another mentally handicapped, the third chronically weak with
children born blind.
Vietnam estimates 400,000 people were killed or
maimed by the defoliants, 500,000 children have been born with defects from
retardation to spina bifida and a further two million people have suffered
cancers or other illnesses. Yet they have received no compensation from those
who produced the chemicals and those who made them a weapon of war.
Vinh survives on a $60 monthly pension – far from enough to cover his medical
expenses, let alone those of his children. "We hope the U.S. will provide help
for us," he says quietly.
So far, that seems unlikely. In February, a
U.S. court rejected the latest appeal by Vietnamese victims who were suing the
manufacturers of Agent Orange for billions in compensation. As an act of
charity, Washington has offered a paltry $3-million not only to help treat the
victims of America's biggest experiment with chemical-warfare tactics but to
clean up the contamination that keeps adding to the toll.
have suffered the most and received the least help, but they aren't the only
victims. Agent Orange tainted everyone it touched, and so binds Vietnam not only
to the United States, whose fighters also paid a price for the misery they
created, but to Canada as well.
More than two decades after ailing U.S.
veterans were awarded $180-million in compensation (in addition to the billions
spent on their medical care), Ottawa is offering $20,000 each to an estimated
4,500 Canadian soldiers and civilians exposed when Agent Orange was secretly
tested on a New Brunswick military base.
And just as Vietnam continues to
press a stubborn U.S. government to help clean up the damage Agent Orange
caused, a sleepy Ontario farming town is still struggling 40 years after the
fact to rid itself of the fallout from a local chemical plant that brewed up
millions of litres of the stuff for the U.S war effort.
WELCOME TO THE HOME OF THE
Susan Bryant steers her silver Toyota down a gravel lane
in a cemetery overlooking Elmira, a community of 12,000 surrounded by lush
farmland about 15 kilometres north of Kitchener-Waterloo, Ont.
59-year-old English instructor at the University of Waterloo isn't here to
commune with the dead. "There's the toxidome," she says, pointing beyond the
barbed-wire fence to a massive, windowless structure. "My favourite view is
looking back through the headstones."
Being next to a cemetery is a
fitting location because the building is a kind of tomb – one designed to house
the putrid remains of Canada's contribution to the Vietnam War. In the 1960s,
the plant now known as Chemtura was owned by Uniroyal Ltd., one of seven
suppliers of Agent Orange to the American military. About 2.6 million litres of
the herbicide sprayed on the jungles and people of Vietnam were made here.
And like Vietnam, Elmira remains tainted by the experience: Dioxin still
pollutes the soil in parts of town, its groundwater and, some whisper, its
The dome housed more than 46,000 tonnes of toxic waste that was
generated by the plant, excavated in 1993 – more than two decades after Agent
Orange production halted – and eventually shipped to a hazardous-waste landfill
site near Sarnia, Ont. And yet the province has ordered a further cleanup, and
local wells remain so poisoned that drinking water has to be piped in from
Even the cemetery is affected: The area adjoining the plant's
old dumping ground is still too contaminated for burials. "I think," Ms. Bryant
says dryly, "it could be a selling point: 'You will never decay. You will be
This long after the fact, few Canadians are aware of their
country's infamous role in Vietnam, but the past weighs heavily on
"You'd do it all differently now," says Fred Hager, a chemical
engineer who spent his 42-year career at the plant before retiring in 1986 as
head of research and development. "Everybody would."
Now 88 and still a
resident of Elmira, Mr. Hager will never forget the day in 1970 he travelled to
Ottawa to test Uni-royal's herbicide with a new machine that could detect dioxin
as low as one part per billion. The reading came back at more than one part per
million – 10 times the level now generally considered safe.
shut the whole damn thing down," he says, "and made no
BEWARE THE LAKE OF
THE KILLER FISH
The U.S. began experimenting with defoliants in
Vietnam in 1961, giving its first lethal herbicides such names as Agent Purple,
Agent Blue, Agent Green, Agent White and Agent Pink after the colour of an
identifying band on the drums in which they were stored.
which was based on research Mr. Galston had conducted at the University of
Illinois just before the Second World War (others used his research notes after
he enlisted), was the last and most potent concoction employed in the
defoliation campaign initially called Operation Hades (later renamed Operation
Despite warnings that it could harm humans, an estimated
4.8 million Vietnamese were exposed. To make matters worse, the chemical was
sprayed in concentrations higher than anything recommended for weed clearance
even though by then the toxic effects of dioxin were well known. (Just
one-millionth of a gram per kilo of body weight can cause birth defects and
reproductive failure in laboratory animals.)
In total, the equivalent of
at least 366 kilograms of pure dioxin were dropped. The compound takes decades
to break down in the environment, and today millions of Vietnamese are still
exposed to it in a series of "hot spots" where Agent Orange was stored during
The cost of cleaning up just three of these sites has been
estimated at $60-million, and an extreme example is Bien Hoa, a town not far
from Ho Chi Minh City where 32,000 litres of Agent Orange that were spilled at
an air base leaked into nearby Lake Bien Hung.
Now a placid pond shaded
by willows in the middle of the town's most popular park, the lake remains
heavily contaminated – sediment samples show dioxin at levels hundreds times
what is safe. It teems with fish, but they are potentially deadly, so warning
signs have been posted and 15 security guards work around the clock to keep
people from catching them.
"Most people know it's contaminated, but they
still go fishing here," one guard says. "We have to call the police to ask them
to enforce the ban."
Nguyen Thi Gai, 66, lives in a one-room house on the
edge of the park, and says her family often ate fish from the lake – until 1995
when tests found dioxin in the blood of her two teenage sons and in a well she
had to stop using.
"I waited for years for the government to provide
medical treatment for my sons," she says. "But they never gave us any treatment.
So I had to treat them with traditional herbs."
This year, Vietnamese
scientists asked for further blood samples from her family, but she refused,
still angry at the lack of treatment.
Hatfield Consultants Ltd., based in
Vancouver, has been documenting dioxin levels in Vietnam. "The lake should be
sealed off and all fishing activities banned," company president Tom Boivin
says. In fact, he adds, "removing the fish population is probably worth
At another hot spot, the former U.S. air base at Danang, a
key staging point for Agent Orange spraying missions, the company took blood
samples from residents, expecting that their dioxin levels might be 10 times the
When some samples were 300 to 400 times that limit,
"my eyes popped out of my head," Mr. Boivin recalls. "They were the highest
levels ever recorded in Vietnam, and among the highest ever found in the world.
If this was Canada or the United States, … the government would immediately
bulldoze the site."
Instead, there have been long and frustrating delays,
he says. "People have been talking about it for 40 years, and only now are they
finally beginning to clean up the sites. It's ridiculous that it's taken so
long. There's been a lot of stonewalling and political bickering. There's no
excuse for it."
The U.S. government, he notes, has repeatedly demanded
proof that the presence of dioxin and the Vietnamese health problems are related
to Agent Orange.
"It's pretty mind-blowing. The Vietnamese had done tons
of research, but they weren't believed until our results came out. The evidence
is so strong. Study after study has clearly demonstrated that these sites are a
very high risk for human health.
"Under international rules, the polluter
pays, so the U.S. clearly has to step up."
So far, the U.S. has been
unwilling to step up, except for the offer of $3-million, which is widely
ridiculed in Vietnam. "That's only a dollar for each victim," says Nguyen Trong
Nhan, vice-president of the Vietnam Association for Victims of Agent Orange.
"How can they survive on a dollar?"
Dr. Nhan's group launched the lawsuit
against the chemical companies in 2004 and now has lost the first two rounds but
is determined to keep fighting. "We are very poor, and these U.S. corporations
are very rich …," he says. "So we know it's very difficult. We must be patient.
But we will continue."
They persist because the damage is far from
finished. "The consequences for humans and the environment are very heavy, not
just from the past 40 years but also for the next 40 years," explains Le Ke Son,
editor of a toxicology magazine and director of a national committee to combat
the effects of Agent Orange.
"There will be consequences for our
great-grandchildren and for our great-great-grandchildren," he says.
has a much heavier impact on Vietnamese veterans than on American veterans. I
think the U.S. government is afraid of these consequences, so they try to find
ways to reject our court cases."
Vietnamese scientists, who have been
studying the effects of Agent Orange for decades, are frustrated by the U.S.
judges and lawyers who demand proof of a link to the devastating illnesses among
Vietnamese veterans. They say that link is as strong as the one between
cigarettes and lung cancer – but the evidence relies on statistical patterns,
rather than documented proof in each case.
Dr. Son cites a recent study
of 47,000 Vietnamese veterans and their children. Those who were exposed to
Agent Orange had a much higher rate of cancer and birth defects. "Even their
grandchildren had a higher rate of cancer."
Another scientist, Nguyen
Ngoc Hung of Hanoi Medical University, points to statistics showing that the
rate of birth defects is far higher in provinces that were heavily sprayed, but
to prove this to the satisfaction of the U.S. courts, he says, may be
THE CASE THEY
THOUGHT WOULD JUST GO AWAY
Coping with chemical fallout is a
familiar burden to the people of Elmira, still grappling with the aftermath of
poor disposal practices for wastes from the manufacture of Agent Orange and
other chemicals. Local wells have been closed since 1990, when hazardous levels
of a carcinogen (this time, not one associated with Agent Orange) was
Yet the Ontario government has given the company until 2028
to clean up the site, and no serious study has looked at whether area cancer
rates are higher than normal.
Why? Activists such as Susan Bryant blame
the politics of denial that characterizes Agent Orange battles around the
For example, it was only after years of lobbying by determined
veterans that Ottawa finally agreed last November to pay $95.6-million for what
happened at Camp Gagetown in 1966 and 1967.
Canadian commanders at the
sprawling military base east of Fredericton needed to have brush cleared to
conduct training exercises, so they struck a deal with the Americans, who needed
a place to test their defoliants.
Former soldier Jim Cadger remembered
seeing planes spew out the powder, green grass turn brown overnight and
Americans soldiers who sauntered into the bar after a day's defoliation. "They
stunk to high hell."
Now, the federal government is paying $20,000 to
those who can prove that they lived on or within a five-kilometre radius of the
base and developed a health problem that is associated with Agent Orange, which
can include several cancers, diabetes and spina bifida, a congenitally malformed
Despite the settlement, a group of veterans and former
Gagetown residents is pressing the government for more damages in a class-action
lawsuit now winding its way through the Federal Court. They claim the 1966-67
time frame is too narrow and effectively shirks responsibility for spraying they
claim went on for years before and after the Americans came to
"The hope is to make the government accountable," says Art
Connolly, a spokesman for Agent Orange Alert, a group also pushing for an
inquiry into the situation. "All we want is the truth … and to me that isn't too
much to ask for."
The Vietnamese are asking for the same.
than 25 years, U.S. veterans of the Vietnam War have received huge sums in
damages and medical benefits from the U.S government and the manufacturers that
supplied it with Agent Orange. In 2006, their South Korean allies received a
$63-million (U.S.) court-ordered settlement from two of the
And now the Canadians at Gagetown have a package that so far
has seen 1,483 cheques worth almost $3-million issued. Even a British soldier
who was there at the time has received a special pension from his
In all, the various payouts surpass $25-billion, but the
chances of the Vietnamese receiving something similar are increasingly
The latest dismissal by their damage suit – which claims the U.S.
chemical companies committed war crimes by supplying Agent Orange – frustrates
supporters, who call it misguided and unfair.
"The government has already
paid 20 to 25 billion dollars to the people who did the spraying," says
Johnathan Moore, a New York lawyer who represented the Vietnamese plaintiffs.
"How can you then deny compensation to those who were sprayed?"
answer to that is a complicated mix of intricate legal manoeuvres, fuzzy science
and the tricky issue of who bears responsibility for the aftermath of
In 1984, after years of arguing over health risks linked to Agent
Orange, the seven chemical companies settled a massive class-action suit by U.S.
veterans for $180-million after a judge persuaded them to buy themselves out of
By 1997, after the last of the money had been paid
out, 291,000 people had received benefits.
For the chemical companies,
the settlement was the final chapter. "The assumption was that this would go
away," says Peter Schuck, a Yale University law professor whose 1987 book
Agent Orange on Trial: Mass Toxic Disasters in the Courts detailed the
But they were wrong. For two decades, they faced a
succession of new lawsuits, all of which were dismissed because, in the eyes of
a U.S. Federal Court, the 1984 case had settled the matter.
2003, the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed an appeals-court decision that allowed
Vietnam veterans who had opted out of the original settlement, or were diagnosed
afterward, to sue the manufacturers.
The door was opened to a new wave
of lawsuits, and American veterans weren't the only ones paying attention.
Around the world, people injured by Agent Orange were inspired to take
In May, 2005, Mr. Cadger, who had worked at Gagetown as a
communications technician, saw a CBC television report revealing that the U.S.
military had tested Agent Orange at the base.
"I remember thinking, 'This
is going to be another government cover-up.' And I got involved."
joined other veterans and former Gagetown residents seeking redress, a group
that included Mr. Connolly, who had spent part of his childhood at the base when
his father worked in the army.
A year later, Mr. Connolly flew to Hanoi
for a conference on illness and pollution related to Agent Orange that was also
attended by delegates from South Korea and the United States.
It was a
depressing trip – he toured an orphanage for children with ghastly deformities –
but inspiring too, he says. A few months earlier, veterans from South Korea –
the United States' biggest ally during the Vietnam War – had won their
$63-million settlement from Dow Chemical and Monsanto. And then, on Sept. 12,
the government of Prime Minister Stephen Harper announced that it would
compensate the Gagetown residents.
Mr. Cadger, who had developed
diabetes, received his $20,000 in December, paid a few bills and banked the
rest. "I took it because I had it coming," he said of the money, "but it angered
me more than anything."
Despite his anger, he conceded that he was
better off than his Vietnamese counterparts. But last month, at the age of 64,
he suffered a heart attack and died.
'WE KEPT HOPING WE WOULD HAVE A HEALTHY
With his health problems and those of his children and
grandchildren, Tong Van Vinh, the former truck driver, tells a sad tale. But it
is no less heartbreaking than those of his roommates at Friendship Village, a
huddle of buildings on the outskirts of Hanoi where Agent Orange survivors
receive temporary respite and health assistance from their government and
Quang Van Tuoi, a 65-year-old veteran of the Viet
Cong, shows a small photo of his youngest daughter, born with deformed limbs and
mental handicaps. Her eyes are glassy and unfocused, and her body is partly
All five of his children, born from 1975 to 1994, have similar
mental problems. "We kept hoping we would have a healthy child," he says. "But
they all suffered the same illness."
Although the Vietnamese government
tries to discourage Agent Orange victims from trying again if their first child
is born disabled, most are impoverished farmers who rely on children for help.
Persuading them to give up their dreams of having a large family isn't
Some can't have children at all. Ha Van Mang, 64, was digging a
bunker when the Agent Orange fell on him in 1968. Ever since, he has endured
numbness and migraine headaches, and after the war, his wife gave birth to a son
with no legs or hands.
The baby died two months later, he says, and "no
matter how sorrowful we were, we were never able to have any more
Mr. Mang's body twitches uncontrollably, day and night, and he
is tormented by rashes that feel like ants crawling on his skin. He feels guilty
that he has been unable to work on his rice farm since 1978.
headaches so strong that it brings tears to my eyes, and sometimes I just cry
and can't do anything else."
Like Jim Cadger, he gets angry when he
thinks of how the U.S. courts have rejected appeals from the only victims of
Agent Orange yet to receive assistance.
"It's an injustice," he says. "An
York is The Globe and Mail's correspondent in Beijing. Hayley Mick is a
Toronto-based reporter with Globe Life.
former director, National Coalition of
Organized Women (NCOW)